Can You Plant a Tree Where One Was Removed?

Can you plant a tree where one was removed? Tree service companies field this type of question regularly. We understand the concern, particularly when it comes to urban forestry and the limited space available. 

The short answer is yes, sometimes. However, you must use reliable tree care techniques to restore the soil’s nutrient balance. In this post, the team from Starwood Tree Service, Cortland’s tree service company, discusses the topic in greater detail. 

When Choosing a New Site Is Better

Arborists prefer to choose new sites for planting after tree removals for a few reasons, including: 

  • Trees are heavy feeders, so the soil they leave behind may be short of essential nutrients. These are nutrients that a sapling needs to grow big and strong. 
  • Sawdust left over from grinding the old tree stump may upset the soil’s microbiome and acidity levels. 
  • Old roots in the ground may get in the way of strong new root development. 
  • If the tree was diseased, the disease might still lurk in the soil. 

What’s most important to consider is why you removed the tree. If it was because of disease, a sapling is likely to attract the same disease. If it was because of poor growth or that the old tree was weak, the soil or position may not be ideal. 

What to Think About If You Must Use the Same Area

Now that you know that the answer to “Can you plant a tree where one was removed?” is maybe, you need the next steps. For the best advice, you should schedule an inspection with arborists. Professional tree care experts will:

  • Check the soil for pathogens and nutrient imbalances.
  • Advise you on the best species to plant.
  • Help you choose a good specimen.
  • Assist in planting the sapling and explaining how to care for it. 

Choose the Tree Wisely

It’s wise to choose a different species of tree, especially if the old one was diseased. The new tree should be resistant to the pathogen. For example, if you lost an oak tree to oak wilt disease, it would be wise to consider planting an apple tree instead. 

It’s also a good idea to select a species with different nutrient requirements. Above all else, choose a sapling that will thrive in the soil that you have available. 

Professionals often recommend choosing a native species. These are adapted to the microclimate and are robust and more easily able to resist disease. 

Give Your New Tree the Best Possible Start

One reason homeowners often balk at planting a tree in the same spot is that you must get rid of all the roots. These rotting roots are prone to disease, will interfere with the soil’s nutrient balance, and can get in the way. 

After you remove the roots, dig a hole that is at least twice the size of your new tree’s root base. This distance gives the roots plenty of room to expand. Then put the sapling in the hole gently, and fill the spaces with high-quality garden soil. 

Finish off with a layer of mulch that extends from the ends of the hole you dug to about an inch or two away from the trunk. 

When to Plant? 

You can plant a new tree in most seasons, but fall is the best time. This allows the tree to grow a strong root system before the growing season in spring. 

Contact the Experts

Would you like to know more about tree removal cost and replanting? Now that you know the answer to “Can you plant a tree where one was removed?” and understand the work involved, you may want expert advice. Contact us at Starwood Tree Service at (330) 231-5022 to schedule a service. 

Call Now Button